• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

New Secular Community Survey

Cheerful Charlie

Contributor
Joined
Nov 10, 2005
Messages
9,357
Location
Houston, Texas
Basic Beliefs
Strong Atheist
https://friendlyatheist.patheos.com/2021...es-survey/

We’re excited to announce the launch of the Secular Communities Survey, the largest-ever study of the community life of secular and non-religious people in the United States. The survey opened yesterday, on March 1st, and will remain open until April 11th. If you’re part of a secular community, we’d love for you to participate. You can take the survey here.

Your chance to be surveyed about your religious orientation. Come on, don't be a wuss!
 
I did it. Do I get a lollipop?

I will say this. I hate surveys that don't have the option of "no opinion" because there are always quite a few questions on surveys like this one that have questions that I don't care or have an opinion on.
 
Done, and I have to agree with sohy. A lot of those questions that had "Strongly Agree --> Strongly Disagree" needed a middle choice for no opinion/don't care.
 
"I believe the following are real:..."

This is a bad question. It begs many assumptions of what people mean when they use the utterances.

Rather,
"I believe _____ are:
>An experience people have because of the stories people tell; a myth
>The product of an internal neural condition
>Supernatural entities
>Natural entities of advanced technology
 
I'd be cautious about interpreting the following questions:

"Does your religious, spiritual, or secular worldiview..

...give you a sense of direction in life."

...give your life a sense of significance and purpose."

...give you strength and comfort."


Some non-religious are likely to say "no" to those things, but not b/c they feel their life lacks purpose or direction or that they lack strength. Rather it can means that they don't rely upon a "worldview" to manufacture these things for them.

Also, it is odd to combine "strength" and "comfort" into the same question since they are in some ways opposites, especially for the non-religious. For example, many non-religious view religion as a way for people to seek comforting delusions because they lack the strength to accept reality, which including coping with the uncertainty inherent to rational thinking.
 
I'd be cautious about interpreting the following questions:

"Does your religious, spiritual, or secular worldiview..

...give you a sense of direction in life."

...give your life a sense of significance and purpose."

...give you strength and comfort."


Some non-religious are likely to say "no" to those things, but not b/c they feel their life lacks purpose or direction or that they lack strength. Rather it can means that they don't rely upon a "worldview" to manufacture these things for them.

Also, it is odd to combine "strength" and "comfort" into the same question since they are in some ways opposites, especially for the non-religious. For example, many non-religious view religion as a way for people to seek comforting delusions because they lack the strength to accept reality, which including coping with the uncertainty inherent to rational thinking.

Ya I took it a few days ago but noticed that also.

A large part of my work is writing, fielding and analyzing surveys and that survey was, in my view, a bit messy in that several questions/response options were subjective and sometimes open to multiple interpretations.

If I had the time or large enough interest I'd do it again and pick it apart but I have neither.
 
Back
Top Bottom